Because it was A Minor.
One gets its miners stuck in shafts, and the other gets its shaft stuck in minors.
He got caught giving alcohol to minors.
Three. One to post it, and two to repost it.
This post.
I did! Well here's the elastic band.
Lake Eerie. Note: This joke has probably been made before.
Tequila Mockingbird!
Hydra-Gin
Because he has his own shoulder to cry on. Edit: all credit goes to /u/Earleebird who posted it in a comment in /r/oldschoolcool
Between you and me, something smells. Credit: Christmas cracker.
Because Peter denied him three times.
Getting denied by a car when hitch-hiking.