They have the same middle name!
Annette !
Is it your right thigh, or your left? Or does the answer lie somewhere in the middle?
EL-ton John
John is a bird.
The same middle name. (Shamelessly stolen from Cortana.)
They both ate honey and they both have the same middle name.
He was trying to find Winnie the Pooh.
When other people put two fingers in his honey.
Neither acknowledge their fellow church-goers at the liquor store.
A Methodist will say "hi" to you at the liquor store